Texas continue to challenge EEOC criminal background check guidance

Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) issued guidance stating that employers cannot maintain blanket policies that exclude persons from employment on the basis of a prior criminal conviction, believing that such policies have a disparate impact against minority and male applicants. Instead, according to the guidance, employers should conduct an individual analysis of the applicant’s criminal history, only excluding such persons from work based on factors such as the age of the conviction, and the relationship between the crime committed and the job itself. The Texas Attorney General filed suit seeking to declare the new guidance an improper expansion of the EEOC’s legislative and regulatory authority, maintaining that felony convictions should automatically exclude applicants from certain jobs within state government. The district court dismissed the lawsuit on procedural grounds, finding that Texas lacked legal standing to sue, and that there was no actual case or controversy to be litigated at that point. However, the Fifth Circuit disagreed (in a 2-1 decision), remanding the suit to the district court for further proceedings. The court rejected the EEOC’s argument that the guidance is nothing more than a statement of the agency’s enforcement position based on existing law. This decision means that the EEOC will be required to substantiate its legal basis for the enforcement they highlight in the guidance. If ultimately rejected by federal courts, the EEOC would be faced with a need to obtain additional legislative or regulatory authority in order to broadly prohibit employers from imposing automatic criminal background exclusions.]]>

You May Also Like

Check out these additional posts from Mind Your Business.

FYI FRIDAYS: What is Live Scan Fingerprinting?

We were able to announce earlier this month that we would offer live scan digital fingerprinting to our clients. MYB has been conducting name-based background checks for over 24 years. This natural progression will allow us to service more industries and provide an all-inclusive background screening service.  It is important to dive further into the…
Read More

Mind Your Business, Inc. Announces Convenient Fingerprinting Program Solutions

Extensive nationwide live scan fingerprinting services provides streamlined solution for MYB customers  March 1, 2021 Hendersonville, N.C. — Mind Your Business, Inc. (MYB), a worldwide leader in background screening, drug testing, EEO investigations, and administrative services is excited to announce the introduction of extensive fingerprinting services to its repertoire of core capabilities. This new service offering will…
Read More


Karen Caruso, Founder/CEO answered a question that many of us have been asked in the last few weeks: What are you looking forward to most in 2021?  I am most looking forward to getting back to some sense of normalcy. I look forward to rebuilding MYB stronger than before. Like many small businesses across the…
Read More

Quality and Precise Results, On Time!

Let us know about your screening needs to get a custom quote. We work with businesses big and small as well as the government. Which means we have a package of solutions for your organization as well.