Study: 1/3 of applicants removed after reference checks

April 2, 2019

In a new survey from global staffing firm Accountemps, senior managers reported they remove approximately one in three candidates (34 percent) from consideration for a position with their company after checking their references.

“Reference checks carry as much weight as any other point in the hiring process, and a misstep here can put you back at square one,” Michael Steinitz, executive director of Accountemps, said.

“Too often, this step is an afterthought, but candidates need to treat it with care and practice proper etiquette. If a reference is caught off guard by a hiring manager’s call, it could impact the conversation or, worse, halt your candidacy altogether.”

See more survey data here.

We run a lot of reference checks for our clients, and we speak to many, many more organizations that have run their own reference checks in the past.

The most concerning thing we see? The lack of care and attention most organizations give to these checks.

They’re a critical part of the of the screening process, but are too often ignore. Here are our tips on the right way to reference check — and why it’s important.

You May Also Like

Check out these additional posts from Mind Your Business.

Choosing the Right Background Check Provider for Continuous Background Checks

Apr 1, 2024
With continuous background checks, the importance of selecting the right provider cannot be overstated. The decision to integrate continuous monitoring into an organization’s processes comes with the responsibility of choosing a background check provider that aligns seamlessly with the unique needs and values of the organization. Let’s explore the key considerations in selecting the ideal…
Read More →

What are Continuous Background Checks?

Feb 2, 2024
Continuous background checks are a departure from traditional screening practices and are a paradigm shift in how companies vet their employees. Unlike the conventional one-and-done approach, continuous background checks involve regular, ongoing assessments of an individual’s criminal history and qualifications. Continuous background checks can be used at varying frequencies, ranging from daily to weekly or…
Read More →

The Top Five Reasons to Run a Background Check

Jan 2, 2024
Running a background check is more than just a precaution; it’s a crucial step toward ensuring transparency, accountability, and peace of mind. Let’s explore why running various types of background checks is essential in various aspects of life.  Hiring the Right Candidates In the hiring process, running a background check is a cornerstone of pre-employment…
Read More →

Quality and Precise Results, On Time!

Let us know about your screening needs to get a custom quote. We work with businesses big and small as well as the government. Which means we have a package of solutions for your organization as well.

Contact One of Our Specialists